Home › Cracked heat exchanger
Cracked Heat Exchanger: What It Means and What to Do (Safety)
We may earn a commission from links on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we make money.
What the heat exchanger does
LibreTexts, a college HVAC course, says a cracked heat exchanger "can allow CO to mix with the air being circulated into the home." ENERGY STAR lists the heat exchanger among the parts a yearly professional check-up looks at, and says a dirty burner or cracked heat exchanger can make equipment run less safely and efficiently.
Signs that can point to a problem
None of these proves a crack. Only a technician can tell. Treat them as reasons to call.
- A CO alarm that sounds or has sounded. ServiceMag says it is a same-day reason to call a technician (see when to call). An alarm shows CO is present, not where it comes from.
- Symptoms in people: the CDC lists headache, dizziness, weakness, upset stomach, vomiting, chest pain and confusion. LibreTexts lists headaches, dizziness, nausea and fatigue.
- A high-limit switch that keeps tripping on a clean filter. ServiceMag says a technician should check for a larger airflow or heat exchanger problem.
- Banging or booming at startup. Budget Heating lists a suspected cracked heat exchanger as a reason to stop DIY troubleshooting. See furnace noises.
- Soot or scorch marks near the burners (ServiceMag, in our call-a-pro guide).
What a technician does
ServiceMag says a technician with a combustion analyzer treats carbon monoxide as "the safety number." It says CO that climbs steadily as the blower comes on is a classic sign of heat exchanger trouble, that a cracked exchanger "belongs on the suspect list" when CO rises, and that the tech should confirm with a visual inspection and a scope before condemning the part. LibreTexts says a technician examines the heat exchanger for cracks or damage and replaces it if needed.
Our advice, not a quote: if a contractor says the heat exchanger is cracked, ask to see how they know, such as a photo or camera view. A second opinion is reasonable. A cracked exchanger is a safety problem, so do not wait.
What to do
- Alarm sounding or someone sick? Get everyone outside and call 911 (NFPA, Madison Fire). CO steps.
- Suspect a problem but no alarm? Turn the furnace off and call a licensed HVAC technician. Do not run it until it is inspected.
- Need heat meanwhile? See no heat tonight and space heater safety. Never use a gas oven or stove for heat.
- Prevent surprises: yearly professional check-up (ENERGY STAR, CPSC) and CO alarms on every level. See how often to service a furnace.
We found no independent source on repair costs or on whether to repair or replace the exchanger, so we give no price. Our repair or replace guide covers the general decision.
No carbon monoxide alarm yet?
CPSC and the NFPA say to have alarms on every level and outside sleeping areas. Look for a UL listing and read the label.
CO and your furnaceSee carbon monoxide alarmsThink the furnace is unsafe?
Gas, burner, ignition and venting problems are for a licensed HVAC technician. Our guide covers which signs mean call now.
When to call an HVAC technicianFind a licensed HVAC pro near youCommon questions
Can a cracked heat exchanger cause carbon monoxide poisoning?
LibreTexts says a cracked heat exchanger can allow CO to mix with the air being circulated into the home.
How do you check a heat exchanger?
ServiceMag says a technician confirms with a visual inspection and a scope, and watches whether CO climbs as the blower comes on. Only a licensed technician should do this.
Related guides
- LibreTexts (Coalinga College HVAC course): Carbon Monoxide (CO) Safety
- ServiceMag (trade publication): Combustion Analysis for Gas Appliances
- ServiceMag (trade publication): Furnace Blowing Cold Air
- Budget Heating (HVAC contractor): What to Do If Your Furnace Is Making a Loud Noise
- ENERGY STAR: Maintenance Checklist
- CDC: About Carbon Monoxide
- NFPA: Get to Know Carbon Monoxide Alarms
- City of Madison Fire Department: Carbon Monoxide Alarms
Free printable: No-Heat Night Checklist
Safety first, then the checks anyone can do and how to stay warm if the furnace stops. Download the one-page PDF now. Want more? Leave your email and we'll send new guides and seasonal reminders now and then.